Last week I was reading a blog post by Rob (at the Heartwood
blog) he had posted on plane totes. He compared plane totes and knobs made by Bill Rittner to LN totes and knobs. I really hadn't given much thought to totes/knobs other than what looked good and what felt good in my hands.
 |
| Bill Rittner knob and tote in cherry |
 |
| Lee Valley knob and tote |
I had Bill make this replacement set soon after I got this jack. To my eye, the LV tote looks like it's undone. Like the person making it went to lunch and before he could finish it someone scooped it up and sold it. It's way too squat and upright for my tastes. I can go either way with the knob from LV because I actually like it better than Bill's. I prefer the low mushroom type knobs that Stanley made too. I got both only because I wanted the knob and tote to be the same.
 |
| LV tote |
Besides me not liking the look of this tote, I think it's too small also. It disappears in my ham hock hand. And I did not like the upright stance I felt went pushing the plane with this tote. The whole feeling of planing changed dramatically for me when I replaced the LV tote and knob with Bill's set.
 |
| this one is perfect |
Of all the planes I have, I like Bill's tote the best. It doesn't disappear in my hands and it's silky smooth everywhere. I especially like how the horn fits right into the space between my thumb and first finger.
The only problem I had with this set is the knob broke. There is a threaded insert in the bottom that is threaded onto a stud on the front of the plane that operates the mouth opening plate. After a couple billion loosen and tighten cycles it quit playing. This isn't a fault of Bill Rittner, it's the insert and the fact it's screwed into end grain. It was gonna go south eventually. I fixed it by putting it back in and using epoxy on the threads. Been quite a while since then and it's still holding up.
 |
| LN tote on my 4 1/2 |
This tote is very similar to Bill's tote. The LN one is a tad bit smaller, but the other lines and form are almost the same.
 |
| not quite as much room on this tote |
The last difference between the Bill and LN totes are the LN totes have a flat on both sides of the tote. There isn't a real hard line showing that but you can see if you put a ruler or a straight edge on it. The tote on my LN 51 has the same tote as this 4 1/2 with the same flats on it. You can't do the ruler trick on Bill's tote because it ain't flat.
The Bill tote is ovalish and there aren't any flats on the tote at all. It's a subtle difference between it and the LN but it pays off in how it feels in my hand.
 |
| my oldest plane - #4 |
I went looking at the totes on the rest of my herd and I started with my oldest plane. This plane is from the 1890's and it's tote is like Bill's in that is doesn't have any flats on it. It's smaller but it has that ovalish look and it feels good in my hand. And it has the low mushroom knob that I like.
 |
| jumped to my #7 |
This is a post WWII plane. The tote is a painted hardwood and I don't know what kind of wood it is. I was expecting this tote to have flats on it like my LN planes but it wasn't so. It isn't as ovalish as the #4 but it still feels good in the hand. A little better then my #4 only because it's bigger. This tote also leans forward a bit more than my #4.
 |
| L to R - LV, LN, stanleys #4-#5-#7 |
 |
| 1970's vintage piece of crap Stanley |
This was the first handplane I ever bought. Now that I have some older Stanleys, LN's and LV handplanes I can see that this plane isn't much better than a paper weight. Look at that hideous plastic tote. To me it's not much better looking than the LV tote. At least the LV has wood as a plus point, plastic owes the scale 10 pts from the git go.
 |
| surprise |
This tote is ugly and plastic but surprisingly, I like the way it feels in my hand. Especially the little hoobie-do down at the bottom where my pinky finger resides. Somehow I doubt that anyone is gonna replicate this in cherry and offer it for sale.
I follow Bill Rittner's
blog and I was surprised when I first saw that he was offering replacement LN totes and knobs. My initial thought was who would want to replace a LN tote? I might do it now that I compared Bill's tote side by side with the LN tote, and also with my herd of Stanleys. It's not a huge difference and I doubt that I'll lose any sleep if I don't do it. But there is no mistaken the feeling of the Bill Rittner tote compared to the others in my hand.
accidental woodworker